Elliot has to pay for it, because, "there ain't no such thing as a free lunch." After taking Elliot to her office, based at a nightclub in Oakland, the Devil convinces Elliot to sign her contract, and delivers further wishes.
Each wish has Elliot living them out with Alison and his co-workers in surrogate roles.
When they arrive at Elliot's home to make love it is revealed that Elliot is gay and living with a flamboyant male partner.
The Devil then appears on the computer screen, pointing out that he only has one wish left.
This is because on their first meeting he asked for a Big Mac and Coke, although she had stated that it was a test wish and granted it before Elliot signed the contract.
After each wish is renounced, Elliot meets with the Devil and she blames him for not being specific enough.
Eventually he returns to work, thinking about what he should do with the last two wishes.